❌

Reading view

The Tokenization Pitch: Turn In Your Gold And ‘Unlock Utility’

Get ready to unscramble your brain after you read this article from the venerable Kitco. You will see why you need to read Crucible of Tokens to unpack the pitch. Either the writer doesn’t understand tokenization, or he is a huckster trying to convert your held gold into a tokenized pool in exchange for asset tokens. Either way, this article intentionally misleads the reader. My comments on each point are in blue. Read this carefully! ⁃ Patrick Wood, Editor.

Although gold is recognized as an essential monetary asset, it is also a dead asset, just sitting on a ledger; however, the tokenization of the precious metal could increase its utility, attracting more capital to the space, according to experts at the London Bullion Market Association’s annual Global Precious Metals Conference.

Editor’s note: If gold is a dead asset, you would be foolish to hang on to it and tokenization is the answer. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

Vincent Domien, Head of Precious Metals Trading at ICBC Standard Bank, said during a panel discussion that while institutional demand for tokenized gold remains relatively low, that could change dramatically once the metal can be put to work more efficiently.

Editor’s note: Institutional demand is very low, but that could change when the public gets involved. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

“I think the biggest thing for me at the moment, especially with price going up, is you have this dead asset on your balance sheet doing absolutely nothing for you,” he said.

Editor’s note: He says it again: physical gold is a dead asset, doing nothing for you.  ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

Domien said that although physical gold can already be used as collateral, the process remains cumbersome, with restrictions around vault locations and significant haircuts. Tokenization could potentially make gold easier to transfer and allow institutions to use their holdings as collateral for swaps or to meet margin requirements.

“If you’re able to tokenize gold and everybody’s able to instantly use it, then suddenly you increase the use of gold dramatically,” he said. “How do we make this asset that lies on everybody’s balance sheet doing nothing, do something?”

Editor’s note: Do you see the target yet: “everybody”. Do you want to stop doing nothing and do something?  ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

Mike Oswin, Global Head of Market Structure and Innovation at the World Gold Council, said unlocking dormant gold could potentially release billions of dollars of new collateral into financial markets.

Editor’s note: Where is this dormant gold? It’s not already in the vaults, but in the hands of the public. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

For the gold market, greater utility could ultimately translate into greater demand.

James Willis, Global Head of Precious Metal Sales at HSBC, said successful digital products could lead to higher gold holdings while encouraging investors and institutions to trade and use the precious metal more frequently. Because properly structured tokens are backed by physical bullion, growing adoption could ultimately feed back into demand for vaulted gold.

Editor’s note:  Make the distinction between “investors” and “institutions”: John Q. Public are the sheep and the institutions are the shearers. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

“If we try and develop a product and we are successful, and we can get something out there into the ecosystem that is useful and helps to expand gold’s utility, potentially this is a good thing for us as a business,” Willis said. “We will see gold holdings go up and we will see people…trading and using gold more frequently.”

Tokenization could also expand gold’s appeal among retail investors.

Editor’s note: Again, the retail investor is enticed. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

Willis pointed to HSBC’s digital gold token in Hong Kong, saying the product attracted new clients even though those investors already had access to physical bullion, ETFs and paper gold products. He said the simplicity of buying and transferring the token helped attract consumers who had not previously been interested in existing options.

The potential market for this is significant. Oswin said the World Gold Council estimates there is between $6 trillion and $7 trillion in retail investment assets, compared with only roughly $50 billion to $60 billion in the retail vaulted-gold and token market.

Editor’s note: They are licking their chops. They have only $50-60 billion in vaulted gold, but $6-7 TRILLION is what they are after.  ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

He added that gold has a unique opportunity in the broader tokenization trend because, unlike many financial assets that already exist electronically, bullion is a physical asset sitting in a vault.

The challenge is using digital infrastructure to mobilize that physical wealth.

Editor’s note: Who holds physical wealth? That would be you until you hand it over to them. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

“It’s physical, it sits in a vault, it needs management,” Oswin said. “It’s so important that we use the innovation now to be able to mobilize and get utility from that physical asset.”

Editor’s note: That dead asset sitting in a private vault… “needs management”. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

However, panelists emphasized that tokenization cannot compromise one of gold’s most fundamental qualities: trust.

The panel noted that any digital representation ultimately has to be backed by physical metal, requiring trusted custodians, clear legal ownership and common standards. James Chapman, Director at Hilltop Consulting, said holders need confidence that actual gold sits behind their digital asset and that they retain enforceable rights to that metal.

Editor’s note:  Um, “trusted custodians”? Clear legal ownership for the institutional vault owners? ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

The World Gold Council is working on a Wholesale Digital Gold initiative designed to combine some of the advantages of allocated and unallocated bullion. The goal is to preserve the legal certainty and ownership rights associated with allocated gold while adding fractionalization and easier transfer and settlement.

Editor’s note:  There is no dispute about ownership of gold that is tokenized: they own it and give you the tokens. ⁃ end of Editor’s note.

Rather than replacing the existing market, Chapman said the project is designed to create a complementary “third” way to hold, transfer and settle bullion.

As Domien noted, investors can be long gold through either an ETF or a token, but the difference is what they can do with the asset once they own it.

Editor’s note:  Another asset class is the ETF (Exchange-Traded Fund). The innuendo is that tokenized gold is superior.- end of Editor’s note.

“In both cases you’re long gold, but you don’t have the same utility out of it,” he said.

Read full story here…

Editor’s note: I urge you to get a copy of Crucible of Tokens right away. Don’t fall for this pap. The only way to hold gold is in your hand! ⁃ end of Editor’s note.
  •  
❌